King Kong: Torgo disapprovesWhat a silly movie.
Not that silly is bad. But it's also an incredibly pretentious movie. Silly and pretentious don't mix well.
I understand that Peter Jackson had to make The Lord of the Rings as 3+ hr epics. They were big books. Tolkien got carried away, so the source material was overblown.
But King Kong is, at its heart, a simple story. People go to Skull Island. Big ape. Big ape comes back to NYC. Havoc ensues. Does it really need to be a 3+ hour movie?
No. Here's how it could be shorter:
1) The old guy at the beginning going back to Chicago -- that plotline exists to highlight Naomi Watts' character's problems keeping friends. That could've been achieved with a line of dialogue, not an entire sequence.
2) Getting Adrien Brody on the boat. Just have him tagging along. The 10 minutes spent on on getting him there against his will is just fluff.
3) Getting to Skull Island. That's practically a movie in itself, none of it good.
4) The natives. Creepy? Yes. In the original? Yes. Appropriate representation of a native culture (no matter how messed up their island may be)? No. The darkest of the dark natives with their crazy ceremonies and bloodlust for white blondes is inherently offensive. Cut that.
5) The bugs in the canyon. Ok, I just don't like bug scenes. Didn't we accomplish this with Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom?
6) Ice skating in the park. Really? A 25-foot ape doesn't just crack the ice? And he doesn't mind the freezing cold? And Naomi Watts is in a thin dress, so there's a fundamental gap in the logic of ice and temperature.
7) The Empire State Building. I swear, if Naomi Watts climbed one more ladder (and, by the way, shouldn't it have been far too cold for all that high-altitude climbing in a nightgown?)... and then the ladder breaks, but Adrien Brody climbs it to come get her.
8) Back to Skull Island, the brontosaurus (or whatever they were) stampede. It was cool, sort of, until the special effects became so transparent that it just seemed sadly fake.
9) Ok, and the first mate/Jimmy story. You know one of those guys is gonna be a red shirt. They're just dragging out the plot so one is a red shirt with emotional resonance. But then, of course, the black guy dies.
10) The T-Rex in the canyon, swinging on the vines, trying to eat Naomi Watts. Just typing that makes me feel dumb.
Ok, ok. Again, silly can be good. Independence Day is a silly movie. It has its pretensions, but it's not over 3 hours long. And it doesn't Frodo the ending by dragging things out. We all know the ape likes the girl but the ape has to fall off the building he climbed. Stop showing me the cameos and in-jokes of the fighter pilots (one is the guy who played Kong in the 70's version! How pointless! Another is Frank Darabont, director of the Shawshank Redemption! How odd!).
And then there are all the slow motion shots, Jack Black making his facial expressions, Adrien Brody looking like Droopy Dog, and, well, ok, that's enough.